These are the final results of the Community Draft Reconsideration Ballot for JSR #76. The Executive Committee for SE/EE has not approved this ballot.

JSR76

StageCommunity Draft Reconsideration Ballot

Ballot durationFeb 13, 2001 to Feb 20, 2001

Votes

SE/EE

Accenture

Apache Software Foundation

Apple Computer, Inc.

BEA Systems

Borland Software Corporation

Caldera Systems

Cisco Systems

Compaq Computer Corporation

Fujitsu Limited

Hewlett-Packard

IBM

Lea, Doug

Oracle

Progress Software

Sun Microsystems, Inc.

WebGain

Vote Log

SE/EE

On 2001-02-20 Progress Software voted Yes with no comment.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 2001-02-20 Apache Software Foundation voted No with the following comment:
Our position remains the same as on January 15th.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 2001-02-20 Oracle voted No with the following comment:
Oracle continues to see merit in the arguments presented by BEA and others and therefore is casting this vote against approval of this specification.  Nevetheless, we appreciate the contributions made by the JSR 76 expert group and encourage the expert group to continue to enhance the specification to work with the new approach for JSR 78 proposed by BEA. 
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 2001-02-20 Borland Software Corporation voted No with the following comment:
None of the concerns raised by the different EC members seemed to have been addressed to anybody's satisfaction.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 2001-02-20 Hewlett-Packard voted No with the following comment:
HP feels this JSR depends strongly on JSR 78 which we can't vote for. The original issues with 78 have not been fully addressed. Perhaps more time would have helped the expert group?
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 2001-02-20 Caldera Systems voted No with the following comment:
In agreement.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 2001-02-19 Compaq Computer Corporation voted No with the following comment:
Compaq agrees with the comments from IBM and BEA and have nothing more to add.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 2001-02-19 IBM voted No with the following comment:
In the previous vote on this JSR, the EC raised concerns about its relationship to J2EE, CS!v2, and IIOP.  These concerns have not been adequately addressed.  The programmatic and protocol-specific approach to security runs counter to the J2EE progamming model where these issues are managed implicitly by the container and are not tied to any particular protocol.  A change has been made to the spec to enable CSIv2 support, which we welcome, but there is still no provision in the spec for implementing CSIv2 over IIOP.  Also, this spec depends on JSR78, which we believe should not proceed to public review in its present form.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 2001-02-18 WebGain voted No with the following comment:
Same reason as before.  We believe this logic should not be in the business code.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 2001-02-18 BEA Systems voted No with the following comment:

Comments would not fit the 1000 character limit. Please see email to seee-ec@Sun.COM sent 25 Feb.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 2001-02-16 Fujitsu Limited voted Yes with no comment.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 2001-02-15 Lea, Doug voted Yes with no comment.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 2001-02-15 Sun Microsystems, Inc. voted Yes with no comment.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 2001-02-14 Cisco Systems voted Yes with no comment.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------